Nothing can ever beat the smile of a happy customer, unless it is an unspecified and unspellable yum sound escaping from a delighted one. Coming a close second, however, are public proclamations of love and support via a good review, or kind customers also taking the time to let all of us on Team Pegasus know what we can do to make our experience even better than before – we are always ready to listen and learn, both via online review or directly via our contact page:

Trip Advisor - Pegasus Coffee Shop

“Fantastic family-run place for great coffee and food!”
Walkingpapers (Los Angeles, CA)

“Great coffee, historic venue…”
DoloresJacoby (West Palm Beach, FL)

“A great place to stop and reflect on wonderful Bainbridge Island…”
NeilJ (Hong Kong, China)

“Very relaxed and friendly atmosphere, with good baked goods…”
allendbi (Bainbridge Island, WA)

For More TripAdvisor Reviews:


Google - Pegasus Coffee Shop

Nice neighborhood place to have coffee and light foods…
Beth Katz (Bainbridge Island, WA)

“Great coffee in a cool place with a wonderful family-owned feeling…”
Suzanne Rico (Los Angeles, CA)

“Old school and legitimate Bainbridge island coffee house!”
Ethan Dubrow (Bainbridge Island, WA)

“Really nice place and great staff!”
Marco B (Seattle, WA)

For More Google Reviews:,-122.5214177,3a,75y,90t


Facebook - Pegasus Coffee Shop

“Adorable family working the kitchen… warm, comforting atmosphere…”
Landon Anson (Eugene, OR)

“Yummy breakfast sandwich, perfect cappuccino, friendly staff…
Nikki Marks (Baltimore, MD)

“So inviting , so knowledgeable and always ready with whatever you need…”
JD TerraMax (Bloomington, MN)

“Seaside cottage vibe, great coffee and delicious inventive healthy food!!”
Michelee Scott (Bainbridge Island, WA)

For More Facebook Reviews:


Yelp - Pegasus Coffee Shop

“A picturesque place covered stem to stern in ivy…”
Justin T. (Lakewood, WA)

“Pastries, scones and cinnamon rolls are the best – really recommend coming here…”
Roslen D. (Port Orchard, WA)

“Nice atmosphere and good food…”
Michelle D. (Bainbridge Island, WA)

“Great spot for a quick breakfast before a long day of training…”
Marc W. (Portland, OR)

For More Yelp Reviews: